Susan M. Boyer's The Sullivan's Island Supper Club is a captivating addition to the Carolina Tales series, blending Southern charm with gripping mystery.

Fans praise Boyer's talent for creating immersive worlds and relatable characters. The story follows Sarabeth Boone, whose dream home turns into a nightmare when a dead body appears on her lawn.

The novel excels in its atmospheric Lowcountry setting, making readers feel like they're actually on Sullivan's Island. The diverse cast of strong female characters and their complex relationships add depth to the story.

While some readers found the multiple character arcs slightly confusing, most agree the mystery payoff is worth it - with many admitting they didn't guess the killer until the very end.

This book particularly shines in its portrayal of women's friendships and community dynamics through the lens of the titular Supper Club. The mix of old and new relationships creates a rich tapestry of Southern life.

Though different from the first book in focus (Hadley takes a backseat here), it expands the world beautifully. Readers recommend starting with 'Beginnings' for better character orientation.

Perfect for fans of cozy mysteries with strong sense of place, this novel delivers both heart and suspense - leaving readers eagerly awaiting Book 3.