Let me start by saying these MAXLINER floor mats have been a game-changer for my 2012 Cadillac SRX. After dealing with flimsy factory mats that let every speck of dirt through, these all-weather liners feel like armor for my car's interior.

The fit is impressive - not quite 100% perfect (I had to work the corners a bit), but easily 90% there. What surprised me most was how well they accommodate the factory snap-in buttons, something many competitors miss. That said, I did notice some sliding on the driver's side during long trips.

Where these mats really shine is in messy situations. During a recent ski trip, they caught all the snow melt and road salt that would have ruined my carpets. Cleaning? A breeze - just pull them out and hose them off. The textured surface hides dirt surprisingly well between cleanings too.

Compared to premium brands like WeatherTech, you're getting similar protection at nearly half the price. While they might not have quite the same 'luxury' feel as some competitors, the value proposition here is hard to beat for everyday protection.

The only real drawbacks? The material is slightly more rigid than I'd prefer (makes folding for storage tricky), and as mentioned earlier, they don't stay perfectly planted on long drives. But considering how well they contain messes and protect my investment, these are minor quibbles.

Final verdict? If you want affordable, no-nonsense protection for your SRX without breaking the bank, these MAXLINER mats deliver where it counts. They've earned their place in my car year-round.