Let's talk about the Medline Moderate Absorbency Underpads. I've used these for both my elderly cat and during a post-surgery recovery period, so I've got some real-world experience to share.

The good stuff first: These pads are surprisingly effective at odor control - a major win when dealing with pet accidents or medical needs. The 23" x 36" size provides decent coverage, and at 150 count, you're getting good value compared to similar products.

Now the not-so-great: As several reviewers noted, these are definitely on the thinner side. While they do absorb liquid adequately, don't expect premium thickness. For my cat's occasional misses, they worked fine, but heavy use might require more frequent changes.

Pro tip: These seem to work best for light to moderate use cases. The ICU nurse's warning in the reviews is valid - if you need heavy-duty protection, you might want to look elsewhere. But for everyday pet accidents or minor medical needs, they get the job done without breaking the bank.

The versatility is impressive though - works for pets (I've tried with both cats and dogs), elderly care, and even post-surgical situations. Just manage your expectations about thickness and absorption speed.