Okay, let me tell you about my WEEK-LONG odyssey to replace a stupid green cable. After AT&T's 'helpful' advice led me to buy FIVE wrong cords (yes, FIVE), this NECABLES one finally worked! Saved me from paying $40 in tools to fix the old one or $100+ for a technician visit.

The good: It's the right RJ11 6P4C connector that AT&T modems need (why don't they just SAY that?!). The 25ft length lets me move my modem away from that ugly wall jack. Connection speed seems identical to the original cable.

The weird: Some reviews claim it's not actually twisted pair like advertised. I ripped mine open and... yep, those wires look pretty flat to me. For my basic DSL it works fine, but if you need legit CAT5 for long distances, buyer beware.

Final thoughts: If you're replacing an AT&T/Frontier DSL cable and just need something that WORKS, this is your $10 hero. But the 'CAT5' labeling seems shady - hence the 4 stars instead of 5.