Let me start by saying, I’ve put these boots through the wringer—hiking muddy trails, trudging through wet grass, and even wearing them as everyday shoes. Here’s the real deal on the Keen Targhee III.

The Good: First off, comfort is king with these. The wide toe box is a dream for my duck feet, and the snug heel keeps everything locked in. They’re lightweight, so I forget I’m wearing hiking boots—until I step into a puddle and remember, “Oh right, waterproof!” And yes, they deliver. No soggy socks after morning dew or surprise stream crossings.

The Bad: Durability is hit or miss. My first pair lasted a solid year of abuse, but the second? Glue failures at the toe bend after just 6 months. Waterproofing vanished like my patience. Keen’s quality control seems shaky—some pairs are tanks; others self-destruct faster than a sandcastle at high tide.

Pro Tip: Size up! I normally wear a 12 but needed a 13 for that perfect fit. Also, rotate pairs if you’re a daily wearer like me—these aren’t indestructible workhorses.

Final Verdict: When they’re good, they’re *great*—like your favorite hoodie with grip soles. But inconsistency makes me side-eye buying another pair. If Keen fixes their glue game, I’d shout from mountaintops about them. For now? A cautious recommendation with backup shoes on standby.