Okay, confession time - I went through THREE different cotton round brands before finding these Amazon Basics ones. And wow, what a difference!

First off, the thickness is perfect. Not those flimsy sheets that disintegrate when you look at them wrong, but not so thick they waste your expensive toners either. Just right for my daily double cleanse routine.

As someone with skin that turns red if you breathe on it wrong, the hypoallergenic claim actually holds up. No irritation even when I'm removing stubborn waterproof mascara (we've all been there with the raccoon eyes at 1am).

The 100-count lasts me about two months of heavy use. Pro tip: I keep them in an old candle jar on my vanity - way cuter than the plastic bag they come in!

Only minor complaint? They're almost too good - I keep forgetting to buy more because the package lasts forever!