Okay, so my dog Sally (yes, named after NBC's Sally!) needed a new collar and this was just TOO perfect. Her old engraved leather one got destroyed by her constant scratching - typical Sally behavior.

The design is amazing - that graveyard scene with Jack and Sally is everything. It's thick and sturdy with a buckle closure (way better than those flimsy watch-style clasps). Followed the size chart and it fits her 12-inch neck perfectly - can slip two fingers under comfortably.

Quality seems great so far after 2 months of daily wear. No fading or peeling of the print, which surprised me since she's always rolling in dirt. The plastic clip feels secure but easy enough to open when needed.

Only minor complaint? The metal D-ring for leashes feels a bit lightweight compared to the rest of the collar. I might reinforce it with an extra split ring just to be safe.

Overall? 10/10 for style and function. Every time we walk past NBC merch at Hot Topic I smirk knowing my pup's collar is cooler than anything they're selling!