Let me start by saying these Boys’ Patent Derby Dress Shoes are undeniably stylish. The wingtip brogue design and lace-up fastening give them a sharp, refined look that’s perfect for weddings, proms, or any formal occasion. I wore them to a family wedding recently, and they definitely turned heads—in a good way!

The velvet-lined collar edge adds a touch of sophistication, and the cushioned insole made them surprisingly comfortable for dress shoes. I was on my feet for hours during the event, and while they weren’t as comfy as sneakers, they held up better than I expected.

However, there are some serious drawbacks you should know about. First off—quality control seems hit or miss. One reviewer found a nail inside their shoe (yikes!), and while I didn’t have that issue, I did notice some uneven stitching on mine. Also be warned: the sizing can be tricky. They run large according to multiple reviews (including mine—I had to exchange for a half size smaller).

The biggest pro? They look absolutely gorgeous with formal wear. Paired with my navy suit, they elevated my entire outfit. But would I buy them again? Maybe—but only if I had time to thoroughly inspect them before wearing and could easily exchange if needed.