As someone who's tried multiple brands for my elderly mother, I can confidently say LivDry's Ultimate XL stands out. The first thing I noticed was how discreet they look - the colored stitching is a simple but genius touch that prevents awkward front/back confusion during rushed changes.

The real test came during a long road trip. Mom wore one for nearly 8 hours (against my usual 4-hour change rule), and there were zero leaks even when she napped sideways in the car. The gathered bands along the legs actually work - no embarrassing damp patches on the seat.

What surprised me most was the comfort factor. The stretch panels move with her body unlike the crinkly, papery feel of cheaper brands. She actually forgets she's wearing protection sometimes, which does wonders for her dignity. That said, I agree with other reviewers about the waist elastic - it could be stronger for active users.

Nighttime is where these truly shine. We tried the 'double-up' trick mentioned in reviews (wearing two with regular underwear over), and it's been life-changing. No more 3 AM sheet changes! The odor control is impressive too - no telltale smells when I help her in the mornings.

Yes, they're pricier than drugstore options, but when you factor in not needing booster pads and fewer middle-of-the-night changes, they've actually saved us money in the long run. Just wish they'd improve that waistband elasticity!