Batman: Year One - Commemorative Edition offers a gritty and urban origin story of Batman, closely following the graphic novel. Fans of the Dark Knight will appreciate the depth and detail in this animated feature.

The 4K Ultra HD presentation enhances the viewing experience with deep blacks and vibrant neon lights, showcasing the HDR capabilities. While not a demo disc, the added color saturation and improved audio make it a worthy upgrade for enthusiasts.

However, some users reported issues with damaged cases and expired digital redeem codes. Additionally, the film's runtime of just over an hour may feel short for some viewers, especially considering the price point.

Despite these drawbacks, Batman: Year One remains a fantastic addition to any collector's library, with great packaging and bonus features on the included Blu-ray. Spanish language and subtitles are also available, making it accessible to a broader audience.

In summary, if you're a Batman fan or a collector of animated films, this edition is worth considering for its story quality and visual enhancements. Just be mindful of potential packaging and code issues.