First off, let me say this sweatshirt is ridiculously soft inside. Like, 'hugging a cloud' soft. I got the stonewash green color and it's exactly as pictured – a nice muted tone that goes with everything.

I'm 5'7" and usually wear medium, but sized up to large based on reviews. Good call! The fit is perfectly oversized without being sloppy. The sleeves are long enough to do that cute thumb-hole thing (even after washing).

Now the not-so-great: After two washes (cold water, hang dry), I noticed slight pilling under the arms. Not terrible, but noticeable if you're picky. The fabric did shrink about half a size lengthwise – my belly button makes occasional appearances now when I reach for things.

Warmth-wise? It's perfect for 50-60°F weather. I wore it apple picking with just a tank underneath and was comfy all day. Wouldn't rely on it for real winter though.

Final verdict? At this price point, it's a solid basic. I'll probably buy another color for layering, but wouldn't use it as my main winter sweatshirt.