Let me start by saying, these cookies are dangerously addictive. The moment I opened the box, the sweet, vanilla-y aroma of birthday cake hit me—no artificial smell, just pure nostalgia in a gluten-free package.

The texture? Perfect. The wafers are crisp but not crunchy, and the creme filling is smooth without being greasy. I may or may not have eaten half a tray in one sitting while binge-watching Netflix.

Now, the sweetness level is... intense. If you’re used to super sugary treats, you’ll love these. But if you prefer subtle flavors, pair them with unsweetened almond milk or (as one reviewer brilliantly suggested) blend them into dairy-free ice cream for a next-level milkshake.

Pro tip: The individually wrapped trays are genius for portion control (lol, who am I kidding) and keeping them fresh. I tossed one in my gym bag as a post-workout reward—yes, I see the irony.

Watch out for inconsistencies though. One batch I ordered had a weird aftertaste, almost chemical-like. Maybe a storage issue? Thankfully, Amazon’s return policy saved me.

Final verdict: 8.5/10. They’re my go-to for cravings, but I’ll never trust myself alone with an entire box again.