First off, the size is fantastic. At 48x36 inches, these pads cover a huge area, perfect for my two energetic beagles who seem to think peeing is an Olympic sport. No more overlapping smaller pads – one of these does the job.

The charcoal layer is a game-changer. Unlike traditional white pads that start looking gross immediately, these stay visually cleaner for longer. Plus, they actually help with odor control. My living room doesn't smell like a kennel anymore.

But here's the catch – durability is hit or miss. When my pups get zoomies on the pad, it sometimes shreds like tissue paper. And while they claim to hold 1200ml, I've had leaks when my senior dog has accidents overnight. The edges especially seem prone to leaking.

For the price, I expected better quality. They're thinner than advertised, and when wet, they become slippery hazards – I nearly did a cartoon-style wipeout one morning. Still, when they work, they're convenient for travel or temporary use.

Final verdict? Good for light use or backup, but not reliable enough for heavy-duty daily potty training. I'll keep buying them for their size, but I'm still searching for the perfect pee pad.