Just got these Dockers Garfield shoes for my husband's church security gig. First impression? They look sharp with those brogue accents – like a proper dress shoe should.

The comfort is hit or miss though. My husband can stand in them for hours, but another reviewer said they hurt like crazy after just 60 minutes. Guess it depends on your feet!

Love that they come in wide widths. Our autistic son usually hates shoes, but kept these on all day at a family event. The latex footbed must be doing something right.

Downside? The 'polished synthetic' upper feels a bit cheap for the price. If you're budget-conscious, they'll pass as dressy... just don't expect premium leather.

Final verdict: 4/5 stars. Great for occasional wear, but maybe not your all-day-every-day shoes.