Okay, first impressions? The heart-shaped packaging is ADORABLE. I felt like a kid opening candy when these arrived. The colors are vibrant and juicy-looking - exactly what I expected from 'jelly' tints.

But wow, was I unprepared for the watery mess! My first application attempt left pink stains on my white desk that still haven't come out. Pro tip: open these over a sink the first time.

As lip stains? Surprisingly good. The color builds nicely and lasts through coffee. As blush? Tricky. I found using a damp beauty blender works best - direct application looks patchy. The cooling effect is nice though, especially when kept in the fridge.

Would I repurchase? Maybe just 1-2 favorite colors. The set is fun for experimenting, but the watery formula makes application messy. Great for teens learning makeup, not ideal for quick touch-ups.