Batman: Year One - Commemorative Edition is a must-have for any Batman fan. This animated movie closely follows the graphic novel, offering a gritty and urban origin story that laid the groundwork for many future Batman films.

The 4K Ultra HD presentation adds depth to the image, with super deep blacks and vibrant neon lights that glow beautifully. The HDR enhances bright colors, making this the best viewing experience for Batman fans.

While the 4K upgrade may not be a 'wow' factor compared to the Blu-ray, the added color saturation, especially in dark scenes, makes it worth the investment. The audio also receives a lovely boost, enhancing the overall experience.

However, some users reported issues with damaged cases and expired digital redeem codes. Additionally, the film's length of just over an hour may feel short for some viewers.

Despite these minor drawbacks, Batman: Year One remains a fantastic story with clear images and sound. It's a great addition to any collection, especially for those who appreciate well-crafted bonus features and packaging.