Let me start by saying, 'Dream State' is a book that will make you feel all the things—frustration, fascination, and even a bit of fury. It's like watching a slow-motion car crash: you know it's going to be messy, but you can't stop staring.

The writing is undeniably sharp. Puchner has a way with words that keeps you hooked, even when the plot drags or the characters make you want to scream. I found myself torn between wanting to ditch the book and needing to know how it all ends. That’s the magic (or curse) of this novel.

The characters are flawed—deeply flawed. Cece, Charlie, and Garrett are messy, complicated, and sometimes downright unlikable. But that’s what makes them feel real. Garrett, in particular, stands out as the loner philosopher who’s both infuriating and relatable. His existential musings hit close to home, especially when he wonders about the meaning of it all.

But here’s the catch: the second half of the book feels like it’s running on fumes. The pacing stumbles, and some characters fade into silhouettes. It’s as if the editor took a nap halfway through. The non-linear timeline, while intriguing at first, becomes exhausting as you leap decades in a single chapter.

Still, there’s something addictive about 'Dream State.' Maybe it’s the raw exploration of relationships—friendship, love, betrayal—or the stunning Montana backdrop that feels like its own character. Or maybe it’s just Puchner’s ability to make you care about people you don’t even like.

Would I recommend it? Yes, but with caveats. If you love literary fiction that punches you in the gut (and then leaves you thinking for days), this is your book. Just be prepared for a bumpy ride.