First off, let me say that this DVD set is a dream come true for classic horse movie lovers. National Velvet, The Story of Seabiscuit, and Black Beauty in one package? Yes, please! The nostalgia hit me hard when I popped in the discs – these are the kind of films that make you want to curl up with a blanket and hot cocoa.

The good: These movies are timeless. Watching them felt like revisiting childhood memories. The emotional storytelling and beautiful cinematography (despite some quality issues) still hold up. I especially loved sharing Black Beauty with my niece – her wide-eyed reactions mirrored mine decades ago.

Now for the reality check: The video quality is... rough. We're talking VHS-level resolution at times, with noticeable graininess. It's watchable if you're not picky, but don't expect crisp HD. Also had a scary moment when one disc initially wouldn't play – needed some gentle cleaning to work.

Biggest complaint? Missing content! Like another reviewer, I was bummed to find Seabiscuit wasn't actually included despite the packaging claim. Felt like ordering a burger and getting no patty.

Pro tip: Check the region coding before buying if you're outside North America. Saw several complaints about incompatible formats.

Final verdict? At this price point, it's decent for casual viewing or introducing kids to classics. But serious collectors should probably hunt down individual remastered editions instead.